Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding

What each one costs, what each is like to live with once it's up, and the extra step new vinyl takes inside Fort Collins city limits.

Light blue-gray lap siding at an inside corner of a one-story house, with white corner trim, a black downspout and a small evergreen shrub in a mulch bed, and garden gloves and a trowel on the ground

Quick Answer

On price, vinyl siding generally costs less than fiber cement, though new vinyl siding inside Fort Collins city limits carries extra work that the usual vinyl prices leave out. Vinyl's color goes in when the panels are made, so they don't need painting. Fiber cement can look like painted wooden boards, with its color added at the factory or after it's up, and like any painted wall it will need a new coat at some point.

Vinyl or Fiber Cement for Your House in Fort Collins

Fort Collins Siding Contractors installs both vinyl and fiber cement around Fort Collins, and we repair both.

What Each One Costs

The typical price to re-side a whole house around Fort Collins in fiber cement is $15,000 to $30,000, for a house with 1,250 to 2,000 or so square feet of wall, tear-off and new trim included. A typical vinyl price is lower, and the Vinyl Siding page sets it out along with the city's rule.

Inside city limits, the extra work for vinyl is a permit plus a fire-rated wall built behind the new panels, and typical vinyl prices don't include that wall. On either material, soft sheathing found behind the old siding is priced on top.

Living With Each One Over the Years

Vinyl asks very little of you day to day. Washing it with a garden hose and a soft brush once in a while keeps it clean, and there's nothing to paint. In hard cold it does stiffen, enough that a knock from a ladder or a baseball can crack it.

Beige vinyl lap siding around a white-trimmed window, with a potted plant and a pair of gloves on the sill and a red watering can and a trowel on the concrete below

Fiber cement asks for paint now and then. When it's time for a fresh coat, you can stay with the color or change it. Changing the color of vinyl means painting it, and our guide on painting vinyl siding goes into what that takes.

If what brought you here is a few vinyl panels that hail cracked, those panels can be swapped out one at a time, and the house can keep the siding it has. If a repair will do, we'll tell you.

More on this: Vinyl Siding in Fort Collins

Questions About Vinyl vs. Fiber Cement Siding

Is concrete siding better than vinyl?

If it's fiber cement you mean by concrete siding, that's a board that mixes cement, sand and wood fibers rather than poured concrete. It's heavier than vinyl and made to resist rot. Whether that makes it better for your house depends on how those points weigh against what vinyl would cost at your address and a color that doesn't need painting.

What looks better than vinyl siding?

That comes down to your taste and the house, and plenty of houses look good in vinyl. If the look you're after is painted wood boards, fiber cement gives you that, and so do engineered wood and real wood. Fiber cement also comes in panels and shingles, and our Fiber Cement Siding page goes through its styles and colors.

Deciding Between Vinyl and Fiber Cement?

Tell us where the house is and what's on the walls now. We'll come out, look the walls over with you, and write up both materials. If the house is inside city limits, the fire-rated wall goes on the vinyl side of the estimate, so you're comparing the two as they'd really go on your house.

Get a Free Estimate
  • Free estimates
  • 10+ years of experience
  • Licensed
  • Insured